Tuesday, November 20, 2012

13 Aug 2012: Sayedee IO cross exam day 48

The tribunal started with the cross examination of the investigation officer in the Sayedee case (following on from this hearing)
Defence: When did you gone to the house of last witness to make him present before the Tribunal? And what is his name?

Witness: I can’t recall when I went. I have sent a representative from the investigation agency to Jessore with the last summons, he has been sent to the Sub Inspector of Jessore district. I even can’t recall how many summons for the witnesses of Jessore have been sent to me, but I have received total 29 summons of witnesses from the Tribunal. I have not asked to the Prosecution to make the rest witnesses present before the Tribunal.

Defence: Whether there was any direction upon you to make any of these witnesses out of those 29 witnesses before the Tribunal?

Witness: Yes, there was direction which was oral.

Defence: There was a fixed place for the witnesses who were being brought from different places.

Witness: Yes. The Investigation Agency was in charge of that place. The personnel of Investigation Agency were all from the Police department.

Defence: On 16-11-2011 witnesses- Md. Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahtab Uddin Hawladar, Mostofa Hawladar, Manik Poshari,Ashish Kumar Mondol, Somor Mistry, Ruhul Amin Nobin, Altaf Hawladar and Abdul Latif Hawladar have been brought.

Witness: I don’t know, but on November, 2011 I have brought witnesses Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahtab Uddin, Mostofa Hawladar, Manik Poshari and Ruhul Amin Nobin from Pirojpur and brought Mizanur Rahman Talukdar from Dhaka; afterwards handed them over to the Investigation Agency and informed the Chief Prosecutor at the same time.
Defence: You have not presented Mizanur Rahman Talukdar on the same date, on his own motion he has came to the witness house on 17-11-2011.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 17-11-2011 witness Sultan Ahmed and the brother in law of Ashish Kumar Mondol named as Gopal Krishno Mistry and his daughter Chondrima Mistry have came to witness house.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 17-11-2011 the witnesses have been briefed at the room of witness house which was fixed for the Prosecutors.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 19-11-2011 at 02:20 P.M. Somor Mistry has been taken to the Rajarbag Police Hospital by Police Ambulance.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 20-1-2011 you have taken the witnesses Ruhul Amin Nabin, Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mizanur Rahman Talukdar to the Tribunal from the witness house.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 20-11-2011 witnesses Ashish Kumar Mondol, Somor Mistry have been taken to the Mohakhali Asthma Hospital for treatment.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: ON 22-11-2011 witnesses Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahtab Uddin, Altaf Hawladar, Abdul Latif Hawladar, Ashish Kumar Mondol, Somor Mistry have been sent back to Pirojpur by the government assigned transport and SI Enamul Haque was with them.

Witness: Not true. But Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahtab Uddin Hawladar, Mostofa Hawladar, Manik Poshari have been sent back to Pirojpur by Bus and witnesse- Mizanur Rahman Talukdar and Ruhul Amin Nobin have stayed at Dhaka.

Defence: On 22-11-2011 witnesses- Ruhul Amin Nobin, Mostofa Hawladar, Manik Poshari Sultan Ahmed have started towards their own home at 04:20 P.M.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 01-12-2011 Syed Shafiqul Islam [Police Inspector (Arms)] has been transferred to the witness house from the Rajarbag Police Station.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 4-12-2011 witnesses Khalilur Rahman, Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahatab Uddin Hawladar, Ruhul Amin Nobin, Manik Poshari, Sultan Ahmed came to witness house and Sonia Ahmed- daughter of Sultan Ahmed was also with them.

Witness: I don’t know. But before 07-12-2011 I have presented witnesses- Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahatab Uddin Hawladar, Mostofa Hawladar, Manik Poshari and RUhul Amin Nobin before the Tribunal.

Defence: On 07-11-2011 you have presented the following witnesses before the Tribunal.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 8-12-2011 the above named witnesses have been brought before the Tribunal.

Witness: Not true. Sultan Ahmed was not present but the other witnesses along with Mizanul Islam have come.

Defence: On 12-12-2011 Mahbubul Alam, Sultan Ahmed, Ruhul Amin have been brought before the Tribunal for deposition.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 14-12-2011 witnesses Mahbubul Alam, Kholilur Rahman have been presented before the Prosecutors?

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 18-12-2011 witnesses- Manik Poshari, Sultan Ahmed, Ruhul Amin Talukdar, Mahtabuddin have again come to the witness house.

Witness: Can’t remember.

Defence: On 19-12-2011 Ruhul Amin Nobin, Mizanul Islam, Mahabubul Alam have been brought before the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 20-12-2011 Police Inspector Afjal Hossain has brought witnesses- Mizanul Islam, Ruhul Amin before the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 21-12-2011 Manik Poshari was sent back to his home because of his mother’s death.

Witness: Yes, but I can’t remember the date.

Defence: On 22-12-2011 witnesses- Mahabubul Alam Hawladar, Mahtab Uddin Hawladar, Sultan Ahmed have been brought before the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 24-11-2011 Mahbubul Alam Hawladar has started towards his house after giving statement.

Witness: Yes, but I can’t remember the date.

Defence: On 26-11-2011 witnesses- Manik Poshari, Mizanul Rahman, Mahtab Uddin Hawladar has come to the witness house with 5 of their relatives.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: Do you know Inspector Obaidullah?

Witness: Yes, he is working at the Investigation Agency.

Defence: On 28-12-2011 a report on the witness house has been sent to Mr. Abdur Rahim of the Investigation Agency.

Witness: May be.

Defence: On 29-11-2011 whether witnesses- Manik Poshari, Sultan Ahmed, Mahatab Uddin Hawladar, Mostofa Hawladar, Mofij Uddin Poshari, Mokles Poshari have come before the Tribunal?

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 30-12-2011 four blankets have been bought for the witnesses for the acute coldness.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 30-12-2011 you along with the other witnesses have attended an invitation at witness Mizanur Rahman Talukdar’s house.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 01-01-2012 witnesses- Mofij Uddin, Sultan Ahmed, Md. Mostofa, Mahbubul Alam Hawladar, Mahtab Uddin Hawladarm Abdul Latif Hawladar have come before the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 02-1-2012 witnesses Mokhles Poshari, Abdul Latif Hawladar, Mostofa Hawladar, Altaf Hawladar have attended the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On the same day Mofijussin Uddin Poshari has left toward his daughter’s house.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 03-1-2012 witnesses Sultan Ahmed and Ashish Kumar Mondol have started towards Pirojpur.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 03-1-2012 witnesse Kholilur Rahman came to the witness house.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 04-1-2012 witnesses- Altaf Hossain Hawladar, Kholilur Rahman, Mahatab Hawladar and Abdul Latil Hawladar came to the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 5-1-2012 witnesses Mahabubul Alam Hawladar, KholilurRahman, Altaf Hawladar, Abdul Latif Hawladar have started towards Pirojpur from the witness house.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 7-1-2012 witnesses- Ayub Ali Hawladar, Jolil SHekh, Basudeb Mistry has arrived at the witness home from Pirojpur.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 10-1-2012 witnesses Jolil Shekh, Basudeb Mistry, Ayub Ali Hawladar have come befoe the Tribunal for giving statements.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On the same day witness Selim Khan has arrived from Pirojpur.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 11-1-2012 and 12-1-2012 Selim Khan has came before the Tribunal by the Police escort.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 12-01-2012 Selim Khan has left towards his daughters home at Azimpur.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: Almost all the mobile number of the witnesses is kept to your custody.

Witness: Yes.

Defence: On 12-1-2012 Mr. Shekhor Chakraborti has come to the witness house as a guest with other witnesses.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 12-1-2012 a DVD player has been transferred from the witness house and you were informed.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 15-11-2012 SI Abdullah AL Baki has gone to the CMM Court Dhaka for giving statement about a case of Sobujbag Police Station.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 15-1-2012 witnesses Gourango Shaha, Mahabubul Alam Hawladar, Abdul Halim Babul have come before the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 16-1-2012 they have again visited the Tribunal.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: If witness Mukund Chakrabarti and Moken Thakur is the same person?

Witness: Yes.

Defence: On the same day witnesses- Anil Chandra Mondol, Fajlur Rahman and other two or three people have come to the witness house.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: Om 16-1-2012 Mukund Chakrabarti, Anil Chandra, Bajlur Rahman, Shekhor Chakrabarti son of Mukund Sheikh and Kamal Shekh have started from the safe house with SI Enamul Haque.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: Do you know SI Enamul Haque?

Witness: Yes. He is working at the Investigation Agency.

Defence: On the same day one SI from Pirojpur has came from Pirojpur with the witnesses Modhusudan Ghorami and Md. Mostofa to the witness house.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 16-1-2012 the Chief Coordinator of the Investigation Agency has called at the witness house and stated that witness Gourango Shaha has given a very good deposition, buy him some sweets and a Panjabi and if requires something more try to give him as far as possible. When the matter has been heard by Mr. Sanaullah of witness, he has also given the same direction. On that time witness Mahbubul Alam Hawladar and Abdul Halim Babul were present. The matter has been recorded on the diary.

Witness: I don’t know anything and I think it is not true.

Defence: On 19-1-2012 Modhusudan Ghorami has been taken to the Central Police Hospital for treatment.

Witness: Yes, but I can’t recall the date.

Defence: On 21-1-2012 he has been taken to BSSMU Hospital from the witness house.

Witness: Yes, but I am not sure about the date.

Defence: After the deposition of Modhusudan Ghorami he was not taken to any Hospital.

Witness: Not true, he was taken to the Police Hospital.

Defence: Before the first day when he attended the Tribunal where was he staying?

Witness: Most probably at the Hospital. He has come to tribunal from the Hospital. I can’t remember whether he has been released on the same date.

Defence: On 30-1-2012 witness Modhusudan got released from the BSMMU Hospital. Afterwards he stayed at the witness house.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 06-02-2012 three bills amounting respectively 4912/-, 4114/- and 4168/- for the month of November, 2011 have been sent to the Investigation Agency.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 8-2-2012 witness Hossain Ali and Sodor Uddin have come before the Tribunal for deposition.

Witness: I can’t remember.

Defence: On 12-2-2012 witness Gourango Shaha has come before the Tribunal.

Witness: I don’t know.

Defence: On 16-2-2012 Mr. Amjad Hossin has brought Mr. Abed Khan from his house of Uttara towards the Tribunal.

Witness: Not true.

Defence: On 12- 2- 2012 at 08: 20 A.M. SI Kalachad Ghosh has started towards the CMM Court No- 31 for giving statement on a case of Chokbazar Police Station .

Witness: I don’t know. There is a place intended for keeping the witness for the deposition purpose which is titled as safe house, but intentionally you are mentioning it as witness house.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: You are informed about every matters of witness house.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: On 31-01-2012 witness Sumoti Rani Mondol has at first been taken to the witness house and her son Ashish Kumar Mondol and Somor Mistry were also present.

Defence: I can’t remember the date.

Witness: Till 16-3-2012 Ashish Kumar Mondol and Somor Mistry used to stay at frequently at the witness house and sometimes gone their own houses.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: They were still in the witness house when the last day fixed for the Tribunal to present the witnesses in time.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: On 16-3-2012 they have been pressurized to give statement on your teaching.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: Sumoti Rani’s son in law has been brought to the witness house as a part of trick to let them give statement on your accord.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: On 16-3-2012 they have been sent to Pirojpur.

Defence: Not true.

Witness: After sending them to Pirojpur the statement which has been made before the Tribunal by saying that they have fled to India is a false word.

Defence: Not true. 
 Chairman: The Tribunal is adjourned till 1:30 P.M.
Defence: Did you know whether the father and any relatives of Sumoti Rani was killed during the Liberation War or not?

Witness: It is not in my record.

Defence: Did you know whether there is any relative of the Suren Mandol and Jageshawr Mondol?

Witness: I can not find it in my investigation.

Defence: Who is the director of the Razakaar force till 16th December 1971?

Witness: I cannot remember.

Defence: 3 sisters of Gowranga Saha who were raped were under the age of six.

Witness: It is not true.

Defence: you have given false statement.

Witness: It is not true.

No comments:

Post a Comment